The Cellar is a great place with great people. Some of us are more argumentative than others, though.
For instance...I have a cat that really, really likes to go outside. It is obviously in her nature to do so. She was a stray when we got her, although very young. She goes absolutely apeshit if she can't go outside several times a day. So...
Do I keep her in so nothing bad happens to her, do I let her out because it is in her nature, or should I have never picked her up in the first place?