The Cellar - View Single Post

gvidas · 10-26-2010, 01:26 PM

I believe a better way to put it is:

"First choice" votes are tallied. If there is no clear winner (50% majority), a certain number of absolutely-losing candidates are removed from the running (all but the top two, or whatever, depending on interpretation.) The votes of the just-now-eliminated candidates are re-distributed to the remaining candidate based on the 2nd and third choices of the voters in question.

I.e.,

Bush and Gore each get 49% of the vote. Nader gets 1%, and Alf gets 1%. Nader and Alf are both out of the running, and the votes they had received are given to Bush and Gore based on the voter's preferences. If you voted Alf #1, Bush #2, your vote is tallied for Bush after Alf is eliminated; if you voted Alf #1, Nader #2, Gore #3, your vote is tallied for Gore after Alf and Nader are eliminated.

It's still one (wo)man, one vote. But you can show your support for snowball-chance-in-hell candidates without having to sacrifice the 'lesser of two evils' consideration.

10-26-2010, 01:26 PM	#7
gvidas Hoodoo Guru Join Date: Jul 2009 Posts: 286	I believe a better way to put it is: "First choice" votes are tallied. If there is no clear winner (50% majority), a certain number of absolutely-losing candidates are removed from the running (all but the top two, or whatever, depending on interpretation.) The votes of the just-now-eliminated candidates are re-distributed to the remaining candidate based on the 2nd and third choices of the voters in question. I.e., Bush and Gore each get 49% of the vote. Nader gets 1%, and Alf gets 1%. Nader and Alf are both out of the running, and the votes they had received are given to Bush and Gore based on the voter's preferences. If you voted Alf #1, Bush #2, your vote is tallied for Bush after Alf is eliminated; if you voted Alf #1, Nader #2, Gore #3, your vote is tallied for Gore after Alf and Nader are eliminated. It's still one (wo)man, one vote. But you can show your support for snowball-chance-in-hell candidates without having to sacrifice the 'lesser of two evils' consideration.