I'm not offended or anything.
btw, the question in the "poll" is How would you rate this thread? not How do you like this idea?
I agree with you that we as a community have to think this through and discuss it and figure out what would likely work ... and that's exactly what this thread is about.
I find it hard to believe that this is a Horrible thread that we should not be discussing here.
Of course, if it really is, we should get off this thread soon ... and that's the point.