All The Young Dudes
I'm Gonna Be (500 Miles)
The Boxer
Pigs
Sweet Caroline

All The Young Dudes
The Boxer
Where It's At
War Pigs

Dudes 2, Sedated 2. Break the tie!

Dudes

Vote for as many as you like:

The Wizard vs. Linger
Imagine vs. Glycerine
Helplessly Hoping vs. Simple Man
Shock the Monkey vs. Comfortably Numb
Black vs. Black Velvet



The current field of 64

And I did not pair Black vs Black Velvet on purpose. If I did, I would've put Us and Them against And You And I, and Pigs against War Pigs, and I Alone against I Am I Said.

The Wizard
Imagine
Simple Man
Comfortably Numb

And Clocks against 25 or 6 to 4 (which many people don't know, but the song is about that time of night, 3:34-3:35 AM)

Linger
Glycerine
Comfortably Numb
Black Velvet

The Wizard
Black
Glycerine
Comfortably Numb

what WAS the method?

In this case I just sorted by number of seconds, which led to too much randomness in the grouping because most songs had two or three seconds.

Imagine
Simple Man
Comfortably Numb

I'm way too unfocused to know, but if it's still on the block I'll pick 25 or 6 to 4. Ahhh, Chicago in their best times. Love the horns.

Linger
Imagine

Edit: and Comfortably Numb (but I think that one already won)