I believe the "new" FISA was not much different from the way it was prior to Bush, and fixed some of the problems that the Bush admin said they had with it, like a significantly faster turn around time fro approval of wire taps on actionable intell. And that was a good thing.
|
The differences may be small, but they were significant in terms of oversight and protection of Americans oversees from warrantless wiretaps.
In fact, the Bush administration, through Gonzales testimony at an oversight hearing, specifically said they did NOT need FISA reform...sadly at the same time they were already exceeding FISA authority with warrantless wiretaps of Americans. |
Quote:
|
with more Congressional oversight...as it should be.
|
Quote:
|
I want checks and balances on any court and any president's use of FISA...and it can certainly be accomplished in closed Intel Committee hearings to protect national security, if necessary.
|
Quote:
|
A leaking sieve is a far better protection against potential Constitutional abuses than no sieve at all.
This is one where most liberals and libertarians agree. |
Quote:
|
IMO, the FISA court should be accountable like any federal court...but with reasonable protection of national security information.
|
Quote:
You'll be amazed at how much you believe is bullshit, if you just look for cites. I know I was, when I first tried to confirm what I knew. Quote:
Also, this is a logical riddle meant to win arguments, which is something less than a proof. "We believe the program was widely abused." "How do you know?" "Because Bush was secretive! We didn't hear anything, that means something was going on!" Ehh, I'll need a little more than that, personally. |
Quote:
IMO, the "leaker" who gave no details that threatened national security, should be applauded. (pardon the echo chamber) |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I would also suggest it was a leak in the most general terms possible by a government employee who had serious and justifiable concerns that laws were potentially being broken and Constitutional rights potentially being violated. There is nothing to suggest that it compromised national security. |
Quote:
Both are mere speculation. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:40 AM. |
Powered by: vBulletin Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.